Nike Pegasus 39 vs Nike Pegasus 40: Which One Should You Choose?
The Nike Pegasus line is a longstanding favorite for runners of all levels. Few models have the same legacy and reputation as the Nike Pegasus series. Loved by runners for its comfort, durability, and overall performance, the Nike Pegasus range has consistently provided quality shoes for runners of all levels. Choosing between the Pegasus 39 and the newer Pegasus 40 can be tricky, so let’s explore the design, comfort, performance, and customer feedback to help you decide which one is the best fit for your running needs.

Quick Comparison:
Here’s a comparison table to summarize the key differences between the Nike Pegasus 39 vs Nike Pegasus 40:
Feature | Nike Pegasus 39 | Nike Pegasus 40 |
---|---|---|
![]() | ![]() | |
Design | Sleek, modern, clean design with classic color options | Bold, modern design with updated color options |
Comfort | Lightweight with breathable upper, great for long runs | Enhanced heel area for better landing and smoother transitions |
Breathability | Highly breathable mesh upper for ventilation | Breathable upper with added stability and smoother stride transition |
Performance | Reliable and durable, good for long-term use | Improved heel area for smoother transitions and better stability |
Durability | Excellent, holds up well over time | Great durability with added performance features |
Customer Feedback | Generally positive, known for comfort and durability | Mixed reviews, with some appreciating the new design and performance upgrades |
Target Audience | Ideal for everyday runners and those seeking comfort | Best for runners looking for enhanced performance and smoother transitions |
Price Range | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Design and Aesthetics
Nike Pegasus 39: A Sleek Classic
The Nike Pegasus 39 features a sleek, modern design that blends style with functionality. The design is simple yet sophisticated, with clean lines and subtle accents. Its color options are diverse, offering a classic look that appeals to a wide audience. The materials used ensure a lightweight feel, making it a favorite for runners who value both aesthetics and comfort.
Nike Pegasus 40: A Bold Step Forward
The Pegasus 40, on the other hand, takes the design up a notch with a more modern and visually striking look. The shoe comes in an updated color palette, offering bold choices like Black/Sail/Jade Ice/Citron Tint. In addition to a great visual appeal, the Pegasus 40 features an optimized heel area that enhances both the shoe’s design and functionality. This design upgrade aims to provide better support during the running stride while ensuring the shoe still feels stylish and contemporary.
Comfort and Breathability
Nike Pegasus 39: Breathable and Lightweight
One of the key strengths of the Pegasus 39 is its comfort. Many runners praise the shoe for its breathable upper, which keeps your feet cool and comfortable during long runs. The lightweight nature of the shoe ensures that your feet won’t feel weighed down, reducing fatigue even on extended runs. The Pegasus 39’s breathable mesh upper helps with air circulation, which is a significant plus for runners in warm conditions.
Nike Pegasus 40: Enhanced Comfort Features
The Nike Pegasus 40 continues the legacy of comfort but adds some refined features. The most notable is the optimized heel area, which not only looks good but enhances the landing and transition from heel to toe. This update is designed to make every step feel smoother and more natural. Whether you’re on a short jog or a long-distance run, the Pegasus 40 keeps your feet comfortable and well-supported throughout. While both shoes are highly breathable, the new heel area on the Pegasus 40 sets it apart slightly in terms of providing a more stable and comfortable run.
Performance and Durability
Nike Pegasus 39: Built for Durability
When it comes to performance, the Nike Pegasus 39 has earned its reputation for durability. Many runners report that the shoe holds up well over time, even after miles and miles of use. Its construction ensures that it can handle the rigors of daily running, whether you’re on the treadmill or hitting the pavement. The support it offers, along with its high-quality cushioning, makes it an excellent choice for runners who prioritize stability and long-term use.
Nike Pegasus 40: Advanced Performance Features
The Nike Pegasus 40, while similar in durability, introduces some key performance upgrades. The enhanced heel area not only looks better but provides better stability when transitioning from one stride to the next. This subtle change can make a big difference in your overall performance, especially if you’re training for a race or focusing on improving your running mechanics. While the Pegasus 39 is known for its sturdiness, the Pegasus 40 improves the overall experience with smoother transitions and a more responsive ride, especially for serious runners.
Customer Feedback and Reviews
Nike Pegasus 39: Highly Praised for Comfort and Durability
Customer reviews for the Pegasus 39 are largely positive, with many users praising the comfort, breathability, and overall durability of the shoe. Runners consistently report that it’s a reliable shoe that provides consistent performance over long periods of use. Some users, however, mention slight discrepancies in color representation from online images, but overall, the reviews are favorable.
Nike Pegasus 40: Mixed Feedback, But Still Strong
The Nike Pegasus 40 has received a more varied set of reviews. Many customers appreciate the enhanced comfort and smoother transitions, with several noting that the shoe feels more stable than previous models. However, there are a few mixed opinions, particularly regarding the initial feel of the shoe. Some runners find the transitions less responsive than expected, while others love the upgrade. Despite these varied opinions, the Pegasus 40 still has strong feedback overall, especially from those who appreciate the new design and performance features.
Conclusion: Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Nike Pegasus 39 and Nike Pegasus 40 are excellent shoes, and each model offers unique benefits for different types of runners.
If you prioritize comfort, breathability, and durability, the Nike Pegasus 39 might be your best choice. It’s a reliable workhorse with a consistent performance record and long-lasting durability, making it ideal for those who need a shoe that will stand the test of time.
However, if you’re looking for enhanced performance features, smoother transitions, and a bold design, the Nike Pegasus 40 might be the better option. The upgraded heel area and overall performance improvements make it a great choice for runners who need that extra edge in comfort and functionality.
And the Winner Is…
While both models have their merits, the Nike Pegasus 40 takes the edge due to its enhanced transition features and performance upgrades. If you’re a runner looking for the latest in design and functionality, the Pegasus 40 is the way to go. That said, the Pegasus 39 remains an excellent choice for those who prefer a proven, reliable shoe.
Happy running, and choose the one that best matches your needs!